Electrolytes Explained: Do We Truly Need Supplements?

Electrolyte supplements are everywhere these days, with brands like LMNT and Gorilla Hydration claiming to revolutionize performance and hydration. But do these products actually deliver? Here, we unpack the buzz to determine whether they’re worth the hype.

Let’s see what Adam MacDonald, a registered performance nutritionist with a Master’s degree, competitive natural bodybuilder, and health and fitness coach, has to say about electrolytes. Adam specializes in breaking down complex health and fitness topics into practical advice.

What Are Electrolytes, and Why Do We Need Them?

Electrolytes are minerals dissolved in water that conduct electrical currents, playing vital roles in fluid balance, muscle contractions, and nerve function. Adam explains that sodium, potassium, and chloride are the key players in this process. While we lose electrolytes through sweat and urine, the average healthy individual can typically meet their needs through diet.

Electrolytes are essential, meaning we must consume them to avoid deficiencies. However, the supplement market has exploded with speculative claims about their necessity during exercise or daily life. This has led to confusion about when and how to use these products.

Breaking Down LMNT and Gorilla Hydration

Products like LMNT and Gorilla Hydration promise to optimize performance and hydration. LMNT contains 1,000 mg of sodium, 200 mg of potassium, and 60 mg of magnesium per serving. Gorilla Hydration features similar ingredients but varies slightly in amounts and includes additional trace elements.

The big question is: Are these supplements effective? Adam points out that research suggests sodium is the only electrolyte lost in significant quantities through sweat, making it the most relevant for performance. Potassium and magnesium, while important for overall health, are rarely depleted to levels requiring supplementation during exercise. For most people, foods like bananas, leafy greens, or nuts can provide these nutrients far more efficiently.

The Role of Sodium in Performance and Hydration

Sodium plays a critical role in maintaining blood volume and hydration, but as Adam highlights, the idea that we all need extra sodium during exercise is overblown. Most of us already consume more than enough sodium through our diets, with the average American intake at 3,600 mg per day—far above recommended levels.

Supplementing sodium might make sense for endurance athletes exercising in hot conditions for prolonged periods (3-4+ hours). For shorter workouts or casual exercise, drinking water and eating a balanced diet are sufficient. Studies show that replacing sodium losses during exercise only improves performance in very specific scenarios, such as ultra-endurance events lasting six or more hours.

The Misconceptions Around Dehydration

Dehydration impacts performance, but the severity depends on the level of fluid loss. Research indicates that losing less than 2% of body weight through sweat has minimal effect on performance. In contrast, significant dehydration (4%+) can impair strength, endurance, and cognitive function.

Interestingly, as Adam notes, our bodies are designed to protect against sodium imbalances during exercise. Sweat is hypotonic, meaning it contains less sodium than blood, which helps maintain stable blood sodium levels even as we sweat. This natural mechanism reduces the likelihood of conditions like hyponatremia (dangerously low blood sodium levels) unless you overhydrate with plain water.

Do You Really Need Electrolyte Supplements?

For most healthy individuals, Adam advises that the answer is no. Here’s why:

Short Workouts (Under 3 Hours): Simply drinking water when thirsty is usually sufficient. Adding a pinch of salt to water or eating salty foods can help if you’re concerned about sodium.

Everyday Activity: The sodium, potassium, and magnesium in a balanced diet—think fruits, vegetables, and minimally processed foods—are more than enough to meet your needs.

Endurance Athletes: If you’re training or competing for extended periods in hot conditions, electrolyte supplements might help maintain hydration. However, exact needs vary based on sweat rate and sodium concentration, so a one-size-fits-all supplement isn’t the answer.

The Cost Factor

Electrolyte supplements like LMNT or Gorilla Hydration come with a hefty price tag, often $45 or more for a month’s supply. Yet, a pinch of table salt or potassium salt in your water can achieve similar results for pennies. Unless you’re an elite endurance athlete, investing in these products is likely unnecessary.

Electrolyte supplements aren’t inherently bad, but Adam believes they’re overhyped for the average person. If you want to use them and believe they benefit you, that’s fine. Just remember that the science supports a more nuanced view:

• Sodium: Relevant for endurance athletes sweating heavily for hours.

• Potassium and Magnesium: Better obtained from whole foods.

• Hydration: Drink to thirst and avoid overhydrating.

For most people, Adam emphasizes that a well-balanced diet and listening to your body are all you need to stay hydrated and perform your best. Critical thinking is essential when navigating the marketing-driven supplement industry and determining what truly benefits your health.

I’m here to support you on your journey to a healthier, fitter life. As always, I appreciate your feedback and suggestions. Let me know what topics you’d like me to cover in future issues by replying to this email.

Want to share DK Does Midlife via text, social media, or email? Just copy and paste this link: https://dkdml.beehiiv.com

For additional content, follow me on Instagram here

Be well,

Dave

Please note: This newsletter is designed for informational purposes only and should not be taken as professional medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare provider for advice tailored to your health and fitness needs.